Factsheet - legal, science and societal support for the fossil ad ban

This factsheet is meant for, e.g., municipal councillors, city boards, journalists and campaigners. It contains science, evidence about societal support and legal proof in support of a fossil ad ban. For other questions, see FAQs.

Last updated: March 2026

Content

The basics of the fossil ad ban

Definition of fossil ads or fossil fuel advertising

Short summary of reasons to ban fossil ads

Fossil advertisements increase CO₂ emissions and pollution, and undermine climate action. Scientists, the UN leaders, health professionals and cities worldwide are calling for a ban. As tobacco advertising has shown, a ban works. It is effective for both climate and health, it’s inexpensive, has societal support and can be implemented tomorrow. Scientists call a fossil ad ban “the low-hanging fruit of climate policy“.

More advertising for fossil fuel products and industries means more fossil fuel use and less information integrity about climate change. This leads to more greenhouse gas emissions, more damage to the climate, more unsustainable norms, less sense of urgency and no (societal support for) effective climate policies. Fossil ads run counter to the necessary phase-out of fossil fuels.

Banning fossil ads to reduce the harm of fossil ads

Fossil advertising:

Banning fossil ads to phase out fossil fuels

  • The world decided in the Paris Agreement that we need to phase out fossil fuels, aiming for climate neutrality by 2050 and a reduction of at least 55% in net greenhouse gas emissions by 2030. 
  • According to the IPCC, the global scientific consensus, as much as 40-70% of the climate reduction target by 2050 depends on government action that leads mass behavioral change, such as banning fossil ads. 
  • The Cambridge Sustainability Commission and many others also referred to advertising restrictions as a lever to accelerate climate action. 
  • It’s therefore that in 2024, the UN Secretary-General Guterres urged “every country to ban advertising from fossil fuel companies”.


Banning fossil ads for planetary health

  • The fossil ad ban can also have positive health effects, as fossil fuels also cause pollution from ell to waste – with dire health effects.


In short

  • More fossil advertising = more CO₂ emissions 
  • Policy for mass behavioural change is crucial (IPCC: 40–70% emission reductions dependent on mass behavioural change)
  • For behavioural change and climate policy, sustainable norms and behaviour and information integrity are crucial
  • Less fossil ads means less climate change and pollution, and better (planetary) health

Fossil advertising should be prohibited because it worsens the climate crisis and undermines the policy that aims to fight the climate crisis.

A tobacco-style ban on fossil advertising

The fossil ad ban campaign is inspired by the fight against the tobacco industry and policies to discourage tobacco use. Tobacco ads are banned in many countries in the world because of the Framework Convention for Tobacco Control by the World Health Organisation. Now it is time for a ban on fossil ads.


Parallels between tobacco and fossil fuels

Both industries share a pattern of harm, denial, political influence and slow change. The main difference is that the harm caused by tobacco is mainly individual and immediate, while the fossil fuel industry is causing a global, long-term crisis (climate change).

Kaupa (2021) presents a comprehensive comparison between the tobacco industry and the fossil fuel industry to explore the possibility of a tobacco-style ban on fossil advertising.

  • “The most important takeaway is that advertising for a harmful commodity can mislead by normalizing it. We saw that the core objective of tobacco control is not merely to provide correct information about the harmful effects of smoking, but to also prevent the impression that tobacco consumption is normal and acceptable, when it is not.”
  • “Ultimately, the most important factor contributing to the continued, misleading normalization of fossil fuels is not the advertisement’s content, but its very existence. The presence of advertising in the public sphere is liable to be viewed as “social proof” that the production and use of fossil fuels continues to be acceptable and normal, even though it is not. Given this, it is hard to imagine fossil fuel advertising that does not mislead, just as it is quite impossible to imagine truthful tobacco advertising.”


Detrimental for health; fossil fuels are the new tobacco

Both the tobacco and the fossil fuel industry produce goods and services that are extremely harmful to public health and the environment. The health-related harm of fossil fuels can be divided into the health effects of fossil fuel-caused climate change and the health effects caused by fossil fuel pollution. 


Health effects caused by fossil fuel induced climate change

Health effects because of climate change, according to a 2023 report of the World Health Organisation:

  • Research shows that 3.6 billion people already live in areas highly susceptible to climate change. Between 2030 and 2050, climate change is expected to cause approximately 250 000 additional deaths per year, from malnutrition, malaria, diarrhoea, and heat stress alone.
  • The direct damage costs to health (excluding costs in health-determining sectors such as agriculture and water and sanitation) is estimated to be between US$ 2–4 billion per year by 2030.


Health effects directly caused by fossil fuels

Air pollution by fossil fuels globally kills more people than smoking. In 2018 1 in 5 deaths were caused by fossil air pollution. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, Director-General of the World Health Organization has referred to air pollution as the “new tobacco”. 

The current direct health effects of fossil fuels are as follows, according to the flagship report Cradle to Grave (2025):

  • Fossil fuels negatively impact health at every stage of their life cycle, from extraction and refining, through transport and combustion, to the legacy of abandoned sites
  • Fossil fuel pollution affects every stage of life, from fetal development to old age. Harms include low birth weight, asthma, cancers, heart disease, dementia, and premature death.
  • Toxins from fossil fuels can harm every part of our body, including our immune system, reproductive system, brain and nervous system, heart, lungs, kidneys, blood and bone marrow.


Lobby and disinformation

Both industries have a long history of aggressive lobbying to delay or prevent regulation. Shared techniques are:

  • Sowing doubt about scientific consensus
  • Emphasising individual responsibility (the consumer is to blame, not the producer)
  • Lobbying policymakers to delay or weaken regulations
  • Front groups and PR campaigns posing as independent experts
  • Delaying tactics (“more research needed”)
  • Sponsoring and advertising 

Interesting reads about the parallels between the fossil fuel industry and tobacco:


Health professionals on the frontline

Health professionals were decisive in the battle against tobacco advertising. They are now leading the battle against fossil advertising as well. Health professionals are active in Canada, Italy, Australia, the Netherlands and worldwide in coalitions like the Global Climate and Health Alliance. See our organisations section.


The proven formula of ad bans 

The ban on tobacco advertising has shown that stopping harmful ads can help protect public health and reduce harm. Only after tobacco ads were banned and disappeared from our daily lives, did people start to fully see how harmful tobacco really was. The ban changed public perceptions of smoking and paved the way for further legislation aimed at reducing tobacco consumption. Just like the ban on tobacco ads, discouraging commercial incentives for fossil fuels is crucial for behaviour change.

A strong case for fossil ad bans

Official advisory bodies to governments: ban fossil ads

Official scientific advisory bodies to the government have advised to ban fossil ads in UK (3 reports) and the Netherlands (10 reports). 

“The broader information environment, including broadcasting, advertising and social media, often contains contradictory, confused and inaccurate messages about behaviour change for climate and environmental goals.”
– House of the Lords (2022) In our hands: Behaviour change for climate and environmental goals

“Major public investment is needed to negate the negative impact of fossil advertising. When fossil advertising is banned, these resources can be better used, for example, to strengthen sustainable options and facilities such as public transport.”
– Committee of 12 behavioural scientists (2023): Ban on fossil advertising is essential


UK

2025 – Dr. Victoria Harvey – Parliamentary Briefing Fossil fuel advertising & sponsorships. 

  • This briefing sets out how and why we should ban fossil fuel advertising and  sponsorship.
  • “To protect UK citizens and support the Government’s objectives on climate, MPs  must now support measures to end fossil fuel advertising in the UK. This is a low cost, high-impact step to reduce mortality, build public trust in the net zero transition, and stop highly profitable polluters misleading the public.”

2023 – Behavioural Insights Team – How to build a Net Zero society by using behavioural insights to decarbonise – for policymakers and businesses

  • In this report, The Behavioural Insights Team advices the UK government on policy that drives behavioural change. They state that governments should regulate advertising and greenwashing.
  • “In addition to cracking down on all forms of greenwashing, follow other countries’ lead by restricting advertising of high-emitting sectors: explore the benefits of banning fossil fuels ads and, in time, advertising from firms within key sectors (e.g. air travel) who fail to meet decarbonisation targets compatible with UK carbon budgets.”

2023 – CAST – The Implications of Behavioural Science for Effective Climate Policy

  • Centre for Climate Change and Social Transformations (CAST) sees restrictions on advertising as a feasible way to reduce demand for air travel. CAST advices governments to restricts advertisements for flying as part of consistent messaging, which they label as very important.
  • “Reducing emissions from aviation will require significant behaviour change and cannot rely on new technology or voluntary industry initiatives.”
  • “Behaviour change can be aided through limitations on the advertising and incentivising of flying by the aviation industry, government, and celebrity culture.”
  • “Contradictory messages from government and industry actors that promote flying activity while also suggesting consumers should make greener choices is likely to inhibit behaviour change and undermine public confidence that the Net Zero transition is a coherent societal project.”

2022 – House of the Lords – In our hands: Behaviour change for climate and environmental goals

  • The House of Lords observe that the UK government is lacking policy for mass behavioural change. The report looked at policies to discourage smoking as an inspiration. It finds that (fossil) advertising regulation is needed to provide truthful information and to reduce emissions.
  • “The Government should introduce measures to regulate advertising of high-carbon and environmentally damaging products.”


The Netherlands

  • The Netherlands Institute for Social Research (SCP) writes in their Climate and Society Report: “It is therefore important to take a broader view and focus on creating an environment that encourages a more sustainable and healthier lifestyle, in which sustainable behavior is easier, more affordable, and more appealing. In addition, it is important to eliminate counterproductive incentives (e.g., fossil fuel subsidies or advertisements promoting highly polluting consumption). (2026)
  • The Scientific Climate Council (WKR) advices the government to aim for behaviour change policy and identifies the fossil ad ban as top-3 measure (2026).
  • An advertising ban is a promising measure for reducing overconsumption. An advertising ban has a wide reach, enjoys broad support and is expected to have a significant impact on behaviour, concludes D&B behavioural research in an advice to the Dutch government (2025). 
  • Simply informing consumers will not get the transition started. The physical and social environment must also change, for instance with a ban on fossil advertisements. This is the advice of CE Delft to the Dutch government (2025).
  • Pricing is not enough for behavioural change. Promoting new standards is also needed. To achieve this, regulating advertising is necessary, advises the Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) to the Dutch government (2023).
  • Banning advertisements is necessary for societal change towards a sustainable economic system: ‘ads for unsustainable products need to be banned over time. Start with banning these ads from public space on a local and national level.’ This is the advice of the Council for Environment and Infrastructure to the Dutch government (2023).
  • Renowned scientific research bureau TNO recommends limiting advertising of climate-taxing products and services. TNO states that the comprehensive ban on tobacco advertising and promotion had a considerable effect on limiting consumption (2023).
  • The Scientific Climate Council (WKR) advises the government to limit advertisements in addition to adjusting pricing on polluting products to change social norms. They state: ‘In addition, the government can more strongly counterbalance the current social norm of consuming a lot, for example by restricting advertisements in public spaces.’ (2023)
  • Committee of 12 behavioural scientists: “Ban on fossil advertising is essential”. The Dutch climate minister has asked behavioural scientists to advise on the added value of a ban on fossil advertising in promoting climate-friendly behaviour. The behavioural scientists see a ban on fossil advertising as a strategically important measure to remove temptations of unsustainable behaviour. (2023)
  • Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency (PBL) advises to ban ads for products with a high environmental impact ahead of EU regulation. 

 

New South Wales (Australia)

  • A New South Wales parliamentary committee has recommended that the state government examine restrictions on fossil fuel advertising and sponsorship, with particular attention to public buildings, transport assets and educational institutions.


Austria

The Climate Advisory Board of the city of Graz proposes to gradually ban advertising for fossil fuels and environmentally unfriendly products from public spaces. The goal is to break the normalization of a polluting lifestyle and thereby accelerate the transition toward a sustainable society. The advisory board emphasizes that such advertisements unnecessarily stimulate demand for harmful products and services, such as SUVs and air travel, which exacerbates global warming and poses risks to public health. Graz bases this proposal on international examples from cities like Haarlem and Amsterdam, as well as legal frameworks that demonstrate that restricting such marketing is both effective and legally feasible under European law. By stopping this promotion, space is created for a positive future vision that focuses on regionality and climate-friendly alternatives. Finally, the board warns that mere warning labels on advertisements are insufficient and counterproductive, as they shift the responsibility too much onto the individual consumer instead of developing the necessary structures for a climate-friendly life.

Public support for a fossil ad ban

Several publications, citizen’s assembly’s and endorsements show the increasing support of a fossil ad ban: 

  • Study: Fossil ad bans are broadly supported across Europe (2025)
    Across 13 EU countries, nearly half (46.6%) of respondents express support for a fossil ad ban, compared to just 24.9% who oppose it. 28,4% is neutral. These results were found by the EU Capable research project that was published in a Nature article. See also societal support data for each individual EU country.

    “Given these findings, fossil fuel advertising bans could serve as a “low-hanging fruit” in climate policy. They are less likely to provoke widespread public backlash and may be a feasible starting point for broader policy packages. For example, such bans could be introduced early in a policy sequencing strategy, reshaping the public information environment and paving the way for more robust and directly impactful measures later. By de-normalizing the fossil fuel consumption, these initial steps could help build public acceptance for policies with greater economic or behavioural impacts.“ 

Legal support for a fossil ad ban

Multiple academic papers and memos by lawyers confirm that a fossil ad ban is lawful. 

International Court of Justice

The ICJ ruled in its 2025 Advisory Opinion that “failure of a State to take appropriate action to protect the climate system from GHG emissions – including through fossil fuel production, fossil fuel consumption, the granting of fossil fuel exploration licences or the provision of fossil fuel subsidies– may constitute an internationally wrongful act which is attributable to that State.” (paragraph 427). This provides legal support to governments, councillors and local policy makers to restrict environmentally harmful advertising in order to encourage behavioural change and makes action imperative.

EU law

  • The Legality of banning fossil ads (2024) Professor Ingo Venzke & dr. Laurens Ankersmit.
    “The main takeaway from the case-law is that the regulation of advertising is not only common but also lawful. It either does not amount to an infringement at all, or if it does, it can be justified on public policy grounds.”
  • Promoting the Apocalypse? The Legality of a Ban on Advertising for Fossil Fuel under European Law (2023) C. Kaupa.
    “It will be concluded that a fossil fuel advertising ban will likely conform to the requirements of European law, especially if it is modeled after the tobacco advertising ban.”
  • A ban on fossil advertising: dire necessity or unauthorized government interference? An assessment of (de)central regulation of fossil advertising against article 10 ECHR (2023). Brouwer & Van Werven.
    “In doing so [not implementing a fossil ad ban, while lagging behind climate targets], the state may not fulfill its active duty of care under, among others, Article 2 ECHR (right to life) to provide effective national remedies to intervene in potentially dangerous situations. Allowing and even facilitating (for a fee) fossil advertising by local governments in their own bus shelters etc. is also strongly counterproductive in light of the very measures being taken to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.”
  • What does EU Law say about Banning Fossil Fuel Advertising? (2024) Prof C. Eckes and Y. van den Bergh.
    “EU law not only allows for stricter interpretation of what constitutes advertising of products and services that are environmentally harmful but even demands such reading starting from a textual reading of Article 9(1)(c)(IV) of the Audiovisual Media Services Directive (AVMSD). This is especially true for fossil fuel advertising considering what we know about the role of fossil fuels in the climate crisis.”
  • Memo – Regulating advertising with a negative environmental impact (for local governments) (2023). mr. Tjarda van der Vijver.
    “In the document, policy officials will find options and frameworks for shaping advertising policies with the aim of banning unwanted advertisements in public spaces. Among other things, it discusses how careful advertising policy can be established. And which routes are possible. Public law or private law.” 


UK law

  • Memo – Legal advice for UK councils introducing a high-carbon ad ban (2023) Richard Wald KD.
    “1. The adoption of an advertising policy banning ‘high-carbon’ advertising is squarely within the powers available to local authorities and therefore prima facie lawful.
    2. The legal risks of adopting a high-carbon advertising ban are limited and the prospect of a successful challenge, low.
    3. Councils have broad scope to design a policy according to their discretion, despite a lack of national definition of ‘high carbon’, with effective precedents already set and working in practice.”


Australian law


US law

  • Does the First Amendment protect fossil fuel companies’ public speech (2023). Katherine G. Horne.
    “The first and second categories of the fossil fuel companies’ speech, related to their products, brand, and reputation, should be classified as false and misleading commercial speech that does not warrant First Amendment protection. A court should find unavailing any argument seeking to protect this speech merely because of its relevance to the debate on climate change. Climate change is irrefutably an issue of immense public importance”


Fossil ad ban passed the legal test

Local climate goals

Municipalities have a duty to protect their people from dangerous climate change. To do this, they must also look for ways to encourage behaviour change – such as a local ad ban – and help reach local and national climate goals. This was confirmed by the International Court of Justice (2025) that confirms that governments have a legally binding obligation to protect the climate, also by limiting consumption. A fossil ad ban is one of the policy measures to protect people by limiting consumption.


Case study The Hague

The city of The Hague in the Netherlands is at risk from climate change because of its location by the sea. The city decided to ban advertising that was causing even more sea level rise. It was inspired by the call of UN chef António Guterres. 


Court case won: fossil ad ban stands its ground

The tourism industry — much like the tobacco industry — did not like the ban. It took the city of The Hague to court. The judge ruled on the basis of EU law that:

  • A local ad ban on a global issue is allowed, especially if it also has a local impact
  • Companies’ freedom of expression can be limited when public interest is more important than financial gain
  •  

The court agreed that less advertising, and therefore fewer flights — along with other climate actions — “could help improve city life and benefit local people”. Even though one city’s action may seem small compared to the global problem, it still matters. Every step counts, and cities, municipalities and local communities “have a right to do their part”.

Read the translation of the verdict and summary of the court case.

Fossil ad ban for (planetary) health and human rights

Human rights

It’s been 10 years since the Paris agreement and ads are stíll promoting the use of fossil fuels. However, slowly world leaders are realizing that the climate crisis is the greatest threat to human rights and human & planetary health in the 21st century.

2026 – Human Rights Council Advisory Committee – Impact of disinformation on the enjoyment and realization of human rights

States should (…) “Ban fossil fuel advertisements, as called for by the Secretary-General and special rapporteurs, and establish robust mechanisms with independent oversight to ensure accountability for both public and non-public entities involved in environmental disinformation;”

2025 –  UN Special Rapporteur – The imperative of defossilizing our economies
The UN Special Rapporteur on Climate Change, Elisa Morgera, calls on countries to ban fossil fuel advertising, promotion and sponsorships. 

2024 – High Commissioner on Human Rights Volker Türk (OHCHR) 

“Finally, it is well past time we phase out fossil fuels, starting with an equitable and immediate phase out of subsidies and a ban on fossil fuel advertising,” says Volker Türk, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, in an open letter at COP29 on priorities for climate policy that is compatible with human rights.

2024 – Secretary General to the United Nations, António Guterres

“Many governments restrict or prohibit advertising for products that harm human health – like tobacco. Some are now doing the same with fossil fuels. I urge every country to ban advertising from fossil fuel companies. And I urge news media and tech companies to stop taking fossil fuel advertising.”

Human and planetary health

2026 –  Green et al. – The health case for a fossil fuel advertising ban
“Bans on fossil fuel advertising could improve health outcomes through multiple mechanisms: reshaping social norms, constraining industry political interference and greenwashing, and directly reducing fossil fuel consumption.”

    2025 – Global Climate and Health Alliance – From Cradle to Grave

    The first comprehensive global overview of the health consequences associated with fossil fuel use at every stage of their lifecycle, from extraction to waste, and across the human lifespan, from pregnancy and pre-birth to old age.

    One of the advices for policy is a fossil ad ban: “Ad bans support climate and health goals by limiting corporate influence over policy and public discourse, while shifting attention and investment toward clean energy.” 

    2024- Anders Nordström – Former Acting Director-General of the World Health Organization (WHO)

    “Just like tobacco advertisements, advertisements for fossil fuel products such as flying or SUVs make these things seem normal and glamorous. Fossil fuel companies greenwash their image by portraying themselves as sustainable. But oil and gas companies account for only 1 percent of total investments in clean energy worldwide.”

    2024 – The Lancet Commission – A just world on a safe planet

    The Lancet Commission names a ban on fossil fuel advertising as one of the measures to stay within the safe and equitable limits of the Earth. “Socio-technical transformations can be supported by standards, certificates, labels, bans on advertisements for harmful products.” – Joyeeta Gupta et al. (2024) .

    2022 – The former WHO Director of the Department of Environment, Maria Neira, has endorsed a fossil ad ban while director.

    2020 – British Medical Journal bans fossil ads

    “For our part, we will not accept advertising or research funded by companies that produce fossil fuels.” The British Medical Journal banned fossil ads and research as part of their divestment strategy. Executive editor Kamran Abbasi announced this in January 2020 with a glowing statement.

    “Health professionals and medical organisations should not accept the world as it is. This is not a matter of playing party politics or anticorporate posturing. Taking action is a duty to the people we serve and to future generations.”

    Science about fossil advertising (bans)

    Fossil ads increase emissions; a fossil ad ban reduces emissions​

    In this section, a selection of science about the harm of fossil ads and the benefits of a fossil ad ban is listed.

    The problem: fossil ads help increase emissions

      • According to this study in Nature ‘Drivers of global tourism carbon emissions‘: emissions from the tourism sector (aviation, cruises, car travel on holidays) contribute to 8,8 -9,9% of the global emissions. This percentage – which does not include substantial non-CO2 radiative forcing – is expected to grow. Tech developments will never make up for the continues growth in demand for tourism. Demand reduction measures are needed (Sun et al, 2024).
      • 70% of all worldwide emissions directly arise from household consumption decisions. Advertising influences consumer behaviour and therefore has a significant, but as yet little researched, relationship with climate change. (Hartmann, 2022)
      • Increased spending on advertising of luxury items means increased individual consumption levels for these items. This is true for all levels of disposable income (Brulle and Young, 2007). 
      • “Fossil industry advertising subverts the Paris objective in multiple ways”, observes Kaupa (2021). It stimulates demand for fossil fuels, which triggers continued investment in carbon infrastructure, rather than in renewable energy or energy-efficient solutions. This, in turn, stymies the transition in many more economic sectors. Fossil fuel advertising plays a crucial role in maintaining and reinforcing the vicious cycle of the “carbon lock-in.” (…) With fossil fuel advertising ceaselessly promoting yesteryear’s carbon-based models of consumption progress is undermined at a critical moment.  
      • Fossil ads drive unnecessary consumption and increase emissions. Worldwide, emissions caused by advertising for airlines and cars alone are estimated between 202 and 606 mtCO2 (Greenpeace et al, 2022). This is the equivalent of the annual emissions of a country like the Netherlands or 29 – 87 coal power plants. 
      • The United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP, 2020) cites advertising regulation as a mechanism for lifestyle change. The UNEP links specific emissions to packages of measures that also include a ban on advertising medium and long haul flights and large, high-carbon private vehicles. UNEP calculated how much CO2 could be saved per capita.
      • “Average consumption per person has increased substantially since 1970 (energy consumption has increased by around 35%, and food consumption by around 25%). Some increases are associated with declining poverty, but wealthy countries and individuals consume disproportionately more because social norms, media, and advertising promote consumption in terms of large homes, automobiles, and frequent air travel.” (Gupta et al., 2024).

    The solution: fossil ad bans help reduce emissions

      • 2022 – IPCC – 6ht assessment report wg3
        The IPCC report states that 40-70% of all emission reductions must come from behavioural change and that regulating advertising for CO2-intensive products as one of the mitigation strategies to reduce emissions. According to the IPCC, a ban on fossil fuel advertising has an effect on CO2-intensive consumption behavior. The IPCC also mentions the normalizing effect of advertisements that encourage CO2-intensive consumption. It can even make people feel that luxury goods are really necessary. “Numerous options exist for such carbon consumption reduction measures, while potentially improving societal well-being, for example: (…) (b) advertising regulation and carbon taxes and fees on high-carbon luxury status goods and services”.


        The IPCC is also critical about misleading advertising by the fossil fuel industry.

      • 2021 – Cambridge Sustainability Commission  – Scaling behavior change for a 1.5 degree world
        ‘Scaling behavior change for a 1.5 degree world’ is the first synthesis report on the contribution of behavioral change to achieving the Paris Agreement target. The Cambridge Institute focuses on empirical evidence for levers for social change. This includes advertising restrictions as a lever to accelerate climate action. “‘Deep’ scaling also requires a more sophisticated understanding of the social and cultural drivers of over-consumption: addressing advertising and the media’s role in the normalisation and reification of high consumption behaviours.”
      • 2020 – Ivanova et al – Quantifying the potential for climate change mitigation of consumption options
        Research into the effect of measures to reduce consumption as a mitigation measure against climate change. A ban on flying and cars is an important part of the measures.“The highest mitigation potential of reviewed options is found in the domain of transport, which is also associated with a substantial carbon footprint in most world regions. The consumption options with the highest mitigation potential advocate reduction in car and air travel, as well as a shift toward less carbon intensive fuel sources, means and modes of transportation.” To reduce overall travel demand and shift to electrical vehicles they advice a ban on flight and car advertising. They also mention a ban on meat advertising.
      • The UN Environmental Programme (UNEP) 2020 report
        The United Nations Environment Programme identifies a ban on advertising of large, high-carbon private vehicles and to a restriction on airline and flight advertising as mechanisms for lifestyle change which can have a substantial mitigation potential to reduce emissions. Also carbon labelling at point of sale for vehicle fuel and other fossil fuel products is mentioned.

    Fossil ads promote polluting norms; a fossil ad ban promotes sustainable norms

    In this section, a selection of science about the effect of fossil ads and a ban on fossil ads on norms and behaviour is listed.

    The problem: fossil ads promote polluting industries, norms and behaviour

    Advertising is an important part of our information environment. Each day, US citizens encounter between 4.000 and 10.000 advertisements on the streets, in the (social) media and in public transport. Because the biggest companies have the biggest advertising budgets, they define what is normal, familiar and desired in society. 

    1. Fossil ads normalise the fossil fuels industry and the use of fossil fuels

    Fossil ads have a discursive, normalising and undermining effect, thereby maintaining the polluting status quo.

      • IPCC (2022): “It [status seeking] can also work to increase emissions through visible and high-carbon intensive consumption items such a larger homes, fuel-inefficient SUVs cars, and long-distance vacations (…). This can lead to the formation of new habits and needs, where products and services become normalized and are quickly perceived as needed, reinforced through social networks and advertisement, making it psychologically easy to convert a luxury item to a perceived necessity.”

    The omnipresence of fossil ads keep fossil fuel products and fossil fuel industries normal and even familiar. This contradicts the sense of urgency of the climate crisis. As long as there is no sense of urgency and fossil fuel products and industries are perceived as familiar, there won’t be enough societal support for ambitious climate policy. 

      • “Partly due to decades of pervasive advertising, products and services with high carbon (equivalent) emissions are deeply embedded in social norms and conventions (for example, driving SUVs and flying to holiday destinations), as well as patterns of production and consumption (‘carbon lock-ins’).” Bouman et al, 2025
      • “The permanent presence of fossil fuel advertising has a strongly normalizing effect: How can the use of a hugely harmful product be discouraged if it is constantly advertised in the media? In the light of the massive and immediate GHG emission reductions needed to achieve the Paris goal, the representation of fossil fuel use as normal and acceptable is factually incorrect. In countries that have signed the Paris Agreement the continued use of fossil fuels at current levels is, as a matter of political fact, highly undesirable.” (Kaupa, 2021)
      • Castro et al (2023) clearly show that fossil fuel advertisements dominate over communication that aims to encourage (non) sustainable norms. “In the presence of advertising for highly known carbon-intensive brands, communicating a social norm [ for example by the government ] is insufficient to induce relevant behavioral changes towards low-carbon consumption.”
      • “The neoliberal market model, aided and abetted by the advertising industry, has monopolised conceptions of the ‘good life’” (Newell, Daley, Twena, 2022). In another scientific paper, the same authors identify “advertising and the media’s role in the normalisation and reification of high consumption behaviours” as the social and cultural drivers of over-consumption – undermining a culture of sufficiency that is needed to reach the Paris goals (Newell, Twena, Daley, 2021).

    2. Fossil ads creates positive associations with polluting products and industries

    With fossil ads, there can be two kinds of positive associations. The one that most springs to mind is greenwashing; images of forests, nature etc. Other positive associations are with holidays, freedom and family. 

      • “The most important takeaway is that advertising for a harmful commodity can mislead by normalizing it. We saw that the core objective of tobacco control is not merely to provide correct information about the harmful effects of smoking, but to also prevent the impression that tobacco consumption is normal and acceptable, when it is not.” (Kaupa, 2021)
      • Fossil ads subconsciously construct a positive association with a brand, influencing people’s attitude and consumer behaviour. Once a positive association is formed unconsiously, people are less inclined to change their minds – even when presented with information that proves the opposite of what was stated in the advertising. (Hütter and Sweldens, 2018)
      • This finding was later confirmed by a study of fossil fuel greenwashing advertising (Friedman and Campbell, 2023): “a single exposure to two 30-second greenwashing ads was indeed sufficient to bolster individuals’ opinions regarding the efforts and progress of fossil fuel corporations in transitioning to renewable energy.” In addition, the researchers found that “when individuals were presented with data revealing the true extent of these companies’ investments in renewables, this diminished, but did not fully reverse, the effects of the ads on their attitudes.”
      • Hartmann et al (2022) describe that “advertising generally involves low-effort rather than high-effort mental processing, as consumers process it while they are performing other tasks, such as scrolling social media or watching television.” This unconsious processing makes it easier for positive associations to nest in the brain. “The effect of these visual cues is so strong that, for example, consumers may perceive a product as not environmentally friendly just because its label does not use green colour.” The authors also note that “consumers—even those with high environmental concern or knowledge—are frequently unable to recognize greenwashing in advertising.”

    3. Fossil ads undermine climate (policy) action

      • Fossil advertising is undermining messages that encourage people to make sustainable choices. “Low-carbon norms have a limited effectiveness in changing consumer preferences in a world dominated by advertising,” is the conclusion of Castro et al (2023). “In the presence of advertising for highly known carbon-intensive brands, communicating a social norm is insufficient to induce relevant behavioral changes towards low-carbon consumption.”“Contradictory messages from government and industry actors that promote flying activity while also suggesting consumers should make greener choices is likely to inhibit behaviour change and undermine public confidence that the Net Zero transition is a coherent societal project.” (CAST, 2023)
      • People who are aware of greenwashing, adopt a cynical attitude towards green products. “Greenwashing represents a significant barrier to emissions reduction“, state Hartmann et al, 2022) “Green advertising scepticism leads consumers to decrease their intention to buy green products. With greenwashing practices getting by unchecked, many consumers will keep purchasing climate unfriendly products and services instead of shifting to low-carbon alternatives.”Seeing an advertisement for air travel, makes people disengage and put greater responsibility for sustainable behaviour on others, instead of on themselves – research by Stubenvoll et al (2021) shows. The majority of people who are not overly concerned about the climate are less likely to recognise the consequences of flying.

    The solution: fossil ad bans promote sustainable norms and behaviour

    In an advice to the Dutch government, scientists identify a fossil ad ban as an “essential” part of climate policy. They state that climate policy without a fossil ad ban is like bailing out a sinking ship. (Bouman, 2023)

    1. Shifts norms and behaviour

    • “Emissions reductions will probably manifest in the long term”, state scientists in Nature, “if a fossil fuel advertising ban is implemented across channels and at scale, as illustrated by the impact of tobacco advertising bans. Such comprehensive bans restrain the ability of companies:
      • to boost aspiration levels further, 
      • to reinforce current fossil-intensive consumption norms and conventions (for example, flying regularly), 
      • and to form new ones, thereby removing an important barrier to the transition to more sustainable consumption patterns.
      • By explicitly rejecting the normalization of fossil fuel products and services, [a fossil ad ban] sends out a powerful message. It:
        • challenges the taken-for-granted nature and moral legitimacy of fossil fuel products and services, 
        • communicates their societal and environmental harms, and 
        • clearly indicates that promotion in the public sphere will not be tolerated.” Bouman et al, 2025

    2. Creates a honest information environment

    • “Moreover, a ban limits opportunities for greenwashing and downplaying fossil fuel impacts, which are known to improve the fossil fuel industry’s image and cloud consumer decisions.” Bouman et al, 2025

    3. Creates a ripple effect (Nature)

    “By rejecting the normalization of fossil fuel promotion, the decision to implement a ban locally can challenge entrenched norms globally, demonstrate government commitment, stimulate public scrutiny and lay the groundwork for broader change. Furthermore, their strengths of low costs, limited implementation requirements and broad public acceptability make them an easily applicable option for municipalities and national legislatures.” Bouman et al, 2025

    4. Opens doors for more climate policy

      • “If demand reduction is the goal, government should avoid its current message of “guilt free flying”, and consider restrictions on the advertising of flying along with clear communications about why reducing demand is necessary to meet climate goals. There is scope for raising the moral considerations around flying as a means of encouraging a shift in social norms, and behavioural leadership can play a role in this.” (CAST, 2023)
      • [Fossil ad] “bans could be introduced early in a policy sequencing strategy”, writes CAPABLE (2025) reshaping the public information environment and paving the way for more robust and directly impactful measures later. By de-normalizing the fossil fuel consumption, these initial steps could help build public acceptance for policies with greater economic or behavioural impacts.”
      • “By shifting social values and norms and making them more sustainable, a ban on fossil advertising can be an essential step towards a social tipping point within the sustainable transition. When people have a stronger feeling that sustainable behavior is widely supported and accepted, they are also more willing to publicly support and share sustainable behavior and choices, with which they can inspire others.” Write Bouman et al, 2023 in an advice to the Dutch government.
      • “In addition, a shift in social norms can pave the way for other policies that are necessary to change consumption patterns. (…) An advertising ban can therefore be a crucial stepping stone to initiate a process towards a sustainable social tipping point, whereby the “spiral of inaction” turns into a “spiral of action.””Bouman et al, 2023 
      • “We conclude that fossil advertising normalizes and promotes unsustainable behavior and discourages sustainable behavior, actively undermining current climate policy. Major government investments are needed to counteract the negative effect of fossil advertising. If fossil advertising is banned, these resources can be better deployed, for example to strengthen sustainable options and facilities such as public transport.”Bouman et al, 2023

    5. Is cheap, widely supported and effective

    Scientists (CAPABLE, 2025) state that fossil ad bans contribute to sustainable norms and behavioural change. “Unlike measures that impose new taxes or mandate behavioural or production changes, advertising bans primarily target the consumer information environment. They are relatively easy to implement and entail limited direct costs for governments or consumers, making them an attractive policy option. Given these findings, fossil fuel advertising bans could serve as a “low-hanging fruit” in climate policy.”

    6. Helps sustainable business innovation 

    A fossil ad ban stimulates product innovation when producers are not allowed to advertise their harmful products. It also opens up the public space for local and sustainable businesses. This way, an advertising ban can be a surprisingly effective driver of ‘innovation’ (McDowall & Underthun, 2025). 

    7. Adds to a social tipping point

      • The Potsdam Institute (2020) cites a ban on fossil product advertising as a measure that contributes to the social tipping point for rapid decarbonisation. Climate measures are mutually reinforcing: e.g., a ban on fossil advertising reinforces measures aimed at increasing climate knowledge. On the other hand, fossil advertising is counteracting against other social tipping interventions like climate education.
      • The shift toward anti-fossil-fuel norms is considered a key social tipping process essential for rapid decarbonization, as social and moral norms are fundamental drivers of human behavior. The targeted intervention to trigger this dynamic is the recognition of anti-fossil-fuel norms. The system of norms and values is characterized by complex, interconnected positive (reinforcing) and negative (balancing or impeding) feedback loops. Advertising by the fossil fuel industry is expected to reduce the group that opposes fossil fuel exploitation, thereby dampening the norm shift. Furthermore, the article notes that a similar balancing loop can occur where media coverage of climate change may lead to higher pro-fossil-fuel advertisements. (Eker, 2024)

    Fossil ads obstruct climate action; a fossil ad ban strenghtens climate action

    In this section, a selection of science about the harm issue and image advertising by the fossil fuel industry (aka greenwashing) and the benefits of a fossil ad ban for information integrity is listed.

    The problem: fossil ads obstruct climate (policy) action

      • IPCC (2022) identifies fossil ads as part of the lobby strategy of fossil fuel companies to derail climate policy, also by shifting the blame to consumers. Fossil fuel companies buy their way into people’s heads: “Who dominates the debate on media, and how open the debate can be varies significantly across countries based on participants’ material and technological power. Fossil fuel industries have unique access to mainstream media via advertisements, shaping narratives of media reports, and exerting political influence.”
      • The greater the threat of regulation to the fossil fuel industry, the more they advertise. This is evident from an analysis of the timing of major public advertising campaigns by five fossil fuel companies in the US over a period of 30 years. “As the perceived level of threat of legislative or regulatory action increases or increased adverse media coverage, major oil companies will expand their efforts to improve their corporate reputation. This effort aims at increasing the perceived legitimacy of these corporations, and in the process, decrease the possibility of regulations or legislation that would change its business operating procedures.” Brulle et al 2019
      • Brulle et al (2019) identify two types of advertising by fossil fuel companies: issue advertising and image advertising.
        • “Issue advertising (also called advocacy advertising, single-issue advertising, controversy advertising, and legislative issue advertising) is the creation of media messages by an organization to advocate its position on political or social issues.”
        • “A second form of advertising is image advertising. It is aimed at increasing the legitimacy and reputation of the organization sponsoring the advertising. They are longer term efforts and are not tied to a specific political issue.”
      • Advertising by fossil fuel multinationals is not the ordinary advertising, say Miller et al (2016). This advertising (‘marketplace advocacy’) serves to protect the market for oil and gas by:
        • maintaining public support
        • promoting policies that favour the fossil fuel industry, for example: free market ideology.

          “Marketplace advocacy campaigns are sponsored by corporations and industry trade groups in an effort to improve or protect the market for their products, usually by influencing a legislative outcome or a public policy debate while maintaining a climate supportive of business activities. Campaign strategies often include deflecting criticism, promoting an organization’s image, laying the groundwork for future policy debates, and/or fostering the values of the free enterprise system. An ultimate goal of marketplace advocacy has been identified as reducing the potential for government intervention in corporate activities.”

      • “Ultimately, the most important factor contributing to the continued, misleading normalization of fossil fuels is not the advertisement’s content, but its very existence. The presence of advertising in the public sphere is liable to be viewed as “social proof” that the production and use of fossil fuels continues to be acceptable and normal, even though it is not. Given this, it is hard to imagine fossil fuel advertising that does not mislead, just as it is quite impossible to imagine truthful tobacco advertising.” (Kaupa, 2021)
      • “The real misleading potential of comparative fossil fuel advertising thus lies not in the provision of incomplete data, but in the fact that relative environmental claims are quickly understood by consumers as absolute. Highlighting relative benefits is thereby liable to obscure absolute harm.” (Gentile and Gupta, 2025)
      • “Moreover, fossil fuel advertising undermines public understanding of and support for the necessary rapid energy transition, creating doubts about the enormously harmful effects of fossil fuels. An already classic example is a Shell ad that depicts flowers growing from the chimneys of a refinery. Such insinuation of an essentially harmless nature of fossil fuels can have a significant deceptive effect on the public. Furthermore, the fossil industry is increasingly claiming to play a positive role in the energy transition. This confuses the public and policymakers about the destructive role these companies have played and continue to play until this day, e.g. by supporting climate denialism, hiding evidence of climate change from the public and vigorously lobbying against stringent climate regulation. As Lyon/Montgomery state: “Even if greenwash does not fool everyone, it may mislead enough people to preempt or delay collective action from emerging – as appears to have happened with climate change legislation.” (Kaupa, 2021)

    The solution: a ban on fossil ads creates information integrity

    • Advertising by the fossil fuel industry is inherently harmful and misleading. Just like tobacco advertising. The industry seems incapable of stopping the deception through self-regulation. That is why it is time for advertising for fossil fuels to be treated in the same way as tobacco. With a total ban. “This article explores under which circumstances fossil fuel advertising must be regarded as misleading, and thus prohibited. Drawing from the example of tobacco regulation it will be argued that advertising is misleading if it “normalizes” a harmful commodity, i.e., if it portrays its production and use as acceptable and normal. It will then be shown that fossil industry advertising systematically “normalizes” fossil fuel products in such a manner, and must therefore typically be understood as misleading.” (Kaupa, 2021)
    • “Dismantling this artificial world, therefore, requires more: a multifaceted approach that dismantles the industry’s narrative control, economic influence, and societal embeddedness. By shifting focus from individual actions to the systemic forces that lock in fossil fuel use, we can more effectively confront the power structures that underpin the fossil fuel industry’s power.” (Gulliver, 2024)

    Where are fossil ads banned?

    Local, regional and national examples

    Already more than 57 municipalities in 10 countries have taken steps against fossil advertising in their public space. Several sports events, newspapers, cultural institutions and universities have banned fossil advertising and or sponsorships. 4 national governments have adopted laws to ban fossil ads or are discussing it.